Skip to content

TexasLDPC v. Broadcom: Can Licensees Sue for Infringement?

AnalystIP 8 min read
License Sue for Patent Infringement
If a patent holder gives another company an exclusive license, can that company sue every infringer on its own? Not automatically. What matters is which rights the license agreement actually transfers.

This question was at the center of TexasLDPC Inc. v. Broadcom Inc. TexasLDPC held an exclusive license from Texas A&M University. It sued Broadcom and others for infringement but it did not add A&M as a plaintiff. The Federal Circuit had to decide whether TexasLDPC had received enough rights to do that.

The court said yes. It found that the license agreement gave TexasLDPC sufficient rights to pursue the infringement action without A&M joining the case. 

The Dispute Between TexasLDPC and Broadcom

The dispute began in December 2018, when TexasLDPC sued Broadcom, LSI Corporation and Avago Technologies in federal court in Delaware. TexasLDPC said the companies infringed patents and copyrights tied to LDPC technology but TexasLDPC did not own those patents. Texas A&M University did and A&M was not part of the lawsuit. 

Years later, the district court dismissed the case, ruling that the lawsuit could not go forward without A&M. The Federal Circuit reversed that decision on September 14, 2026. That decision mattered because it let the case continue. To see why the court ruled this way, it helps to know who the parties were and what the license agreement gave TexasLDPC. 

Why Did the District Court Dismiss the Lawsuit? 

This case was not only about whether Broadcom infringed the patents. The court never reached that question. Instead, the dispute turned on whether TexasLDPC had the right to bring the lawsuit.

The Delaware federal district court threw out the case on two grounds. First, it decided TexasLDPC’s license had ended after the company shifted its business toward enforcement. Second, it decided TexasLDPC could not go forward without Texas A&M, the patent holder joining the case. Either ruling was enough to stop the lawsuit. The Federal Circuit looked at both and disagreed with the district court on each one.

What Does “All Substantial Rights” Mean in Patent Law?

Under U.S. patent law, only a patentee can bring an infringement lawsuit. That usually means the patent holder but the Federal Circuit has said a patent holder can transfer “all substantial rights” in a patent to an exclusive licensee. When that happens, the transfer can be treated as effectively the same as an assignment. The licensee can then sue in its own name without the patent holder.

This does not apply to every exclusive license. A licensee may receive broad commercial rights while the patent holder retains enough control to remain an important party to enforcement. The Federal Circuit therefore examined the specific rights transferred under TexasLDPC’s license agreement rather than treating the word “exclusive” as determinative. 

Key Rights the Court Weighed in Its Analysis

The Federal Circuit did not rely on one single factor. It looked at the whole agreement and a few rights carried the most weight. 
  • The exclusive right to make, use and sell licensed products sat with the licensee, while A&M kept only a small right to use the patents for research and education. This showed who controlled the commercial side of the technology.
  • The license also allowed sublicenses of the same scope. That showed how broad the commercial rights were, since the licensee decided who else could use the technology.
  • On enforcement, the agreement gave the “first and only right” to sue infringers of the patents and copyrights and to collect damages for past, present and future infringement. The court called this a critical factor.
  • The license agreement gave TexasLDPC the exclusive enforcement role against the defendants. This reinforced the breadth of the rights transferred under the license. 
  • The rights generally ran for the full life of the patents, unless the agreement ended under its stated terms. It was not a short-term deal which supported the view that TexasLDPC held a lasting, ownership-like position.

What Rights Did Texas A&M Retain?

This part of the case matters because A&M did not hand over every right. It kept a few for itself. A&M could still practice the patents for research and education. It kept the sole right to enforce against Marvell which already held an earlier non-exclusive license. 

A&M could also take part in certain lawsuits, with limits. It had a say in whether the license agreement could be assigned, though it could not unreasonably refuse and it could end the agreement if TexasLDPC missed certain milestones.

Broadcom relied on these retained rights to argue that A&M remained sufficiently involved in the patents to require its participation in the lawsuit. The Federal Circuit therefore had to assess whether those retained interests were substantial enough to prevent TexasLDPC from enforcing the patents independently.

The Importance of the Right to Enforce the Patents


Courts ask the patent holder to join a lawsuit for two reasons. The first is to protect the accused infringer. A company should not face several lawsuits over the same patent. The second is to protect the patent holder. Its patent could be declared invalid in a case where it had no voice.

The Federal Circuit concluded that the license agreement adequately addressed both concerns. TexasLDPC controlled enforcement against the defendants, while A&M’s retained rights did not create a realistic possibility of competing infringement actions or leave A&M without IP protection of its interests. 

How Did the Federal Circuit Compare TexasLDPC With Earlier Cases? 

The Federal Circuit called this a close call but it found the TexasLDPC license agreement most like the one in Luminara Worldwide v. Liown Electronics. 

There, the licensee had the sole and exclusive right to sue infringers. The patent holder kept some rights but none were strong enough to stop the licensee from suing alone.

Broadcom leaned on Propat International v. RPost instead. In that case, the patent holder could veto licensing and litigation decisions. The court saw that as a major difference, because A&M had no such power here.

The comparison shows why the specific allocation of control matters. An exclusive license can support independent enforcement when the licensee holds sufficiently broad rights, while retained control by the patent holder can lead to a different result. 

The Federal Circuit’s Decision 

The Federal Circuit reversed the district court’s dismissal and sent the case back. Here are the key points of its ruling. 
  • The license did not terminate merely because TexasLDPC shifted its business toward enforcement.
  • TexasLDPC held all substantial rights in the asserted patents.
  • TexasLDPC could therefore pursue the infringement claims without joining A&M.
  • The court also ruled that Texas A&M did not need to be added to the lawsuit under Rule 19(a).
  • The Federal Circuit reversed the dismissal and remanded the case for further proceedings.
  • The court did not decide whether Broadcom infringed the patents.

Lessons From TexasLDPC v. Broadcom for Patent Licensing

The decision shows why an exclusive patent license should be drafted with enforcement in mind. The license agreement should clearly establish the scope of the license, the parties’ enforcement roles, the treatment of damages, sublicenses and the circumstances that could terminate the arrangement. 

The broader point is that an exclusive license can create significant enforcement rights but those rights depend on the structure of the agreement. The parties should understand the litigation consequences of the rights they transfer or retain before a dispute arises. 

What Should Patent Holders and Licensees Learn From the Decision? 

The decision shows how much the details of a license can shape a lawsuit. A few practical lessons stand out for both sides.

Patent Holders 

Patent holders should be clear about what they are handing over. Spell out which rights go to the licensee and which stay with you, especially on enforcement. Think about whether any control you keep could stop the licensee from suing on its own. 

Finally, write the termination terms in plain words. Vague language can start a fight later, even over whether the license still exists. 

Exclusive Licensees 

Exclusive licensees should confirm their enforcement position before bringing an infringement action. They should determine whether the agreement gives them sufficient rights to proceed independently or whether the patent holder needs to participate in the litigation. 

Resolving that question at the licensing stage can help avoid a later dispute over standing or joinder. 

Why Does This Decision Matter for Patent Infringement Litigation?

Before a court looks at infringement, it asks a simpler question: can this party bring the lawsuit? This decision shows that the answer can depend on how the license agreement is built.

For businesses involved in patent licensing, this means enforcement rights should be treated as a central part of the transaction rather than an issue to resolve only after infringement occurs. The allocation of control between the patent holder and licensee can have direct consequences for how future litigation is brought. 

Final Thoughts

TexasLDPC v. Broadcom shows how the setup of a patent license can decide who is legally able to enforce the rights behind it. The Federal Circuit focused on three things: how broad TexasLDPC’s rights were, how limited the interests were that A&M kept and who held the power to enforce.

Patent holders and licensees should think about the courtroom consequences of a license from day one. When an agreement spells out who holds the commercial rights and who holds the enforcement rights, there is less room for doubt if those rights are ever challenged in court.

Stay ahead in intellectual property

Get practical patent and trademark insights, deadlines and news from our team. No spam, unsubscribe any time.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy.